Free guide · 11 min read

Why your nonprofit needs a website and how to choose one

Your website is where every other channel sends people. Search, AI answers, ads, grant applications and your emails all point to it. It needs to help the people you serve find help, let funders check your work, and let donors give in a few taps. Pick a builder your team can update yourselves: Canva, Carrd or Squarespace for a simple site, Wix or WordPress for more control, Shopify or WooCommerce if you sell, or a custom build when the site has to bring people in.

By the Mission Circle team · Updated November 14, 2026

Why does a nonprofit need a website?

Because people look you up before they call, visit or give. A parent searching for after-school care, a funder reading your application and a neighbor deciding where to donate all start in the same place: a search box.

For local organizations, that search usually ends on a website. In BrightLocal’s Local Consumer Review Survey 2026, 71% of consumers said they use Google to find and judge local businesses, and 54% said they visit the website after reading good reviews. The survey asked about businesses, not nonprofits, but a food pantry or a counseling center gets checked the same way.

A Facebook page or a listing on a giving platform helps, but you don’t control either one. Your website is the one place where your programs, your story and your donate button are all yours.

How do people find nonprofits now, including through AI?

Through Google, and more and more through AI assistants that answer the question for them. Both build their answers from what’s written on websites, so if your site is thin or out of date, the answer about you will be too.

The shift is already large. Pew Research Center found in June 2026 that about half of US adults (49%) use AI chatbots, 42% use them to search for information, and 60% have read the AI summaries at the top of search results.

Those summaries change what people click. In a July 2025 Pew study, Google showed an AI summary on 18% of searches. When it did, people clicked a regular result in 8% of visits, against 15% when there was no summary.

So a page that answers the question plainly matters more than it used to. Write who you serve, where, when you’re open and how to get help, in words a stranger would search for. That gives Google and AI tools something accurate to quote, and gives people a reason to click through.

Who is your website for?

Three groups, and each one needs something different from the same site.

The people you serve. They need your hours, who qualifies and how to get help, on a phone and in their language. If someone can’t find your intake form at 9pm, they may not find you at all.

Funders. Grant applications ask for your website, and program officers look you up before and after they read your proposal. They want to see your mission, your programs, who runs the organization and proof of your work, such as an annual report or recent outcomes. No survey measures this, but anyone who has filled in a grant form has seen the website field.

Donors. People who give want to check you first. In the BBB Wise Giving Alliance’s Donor Trust Report 2026, 54% of donors who research before giving said charities’ own websites influence them most.

Then make giving easy. Put a donation form on your own site that takes cards, PayPal, Apple Pay and Google Pay. According to M+R Benchmarks 2026, phones bring 52% of nonprofit website traffic and 43% of online donations, so the form has to work with a thumb.

Asking for a check or cash adds steps, and people give up partway. Cards are how Americans pay now: in Pew’s September 2026 analysis of Atlanta Fed data, cards made up 65% of payments in 2025 (34% credit, 31% debit), and under 1% of people said they prefer to pay by check online.

Why do ads need a good landing page?

Because an ad only gets the click. The page decides whether that person signs up, books or gives.

Google Ad Grants, worth up to $10,000 a month in free search ads, requires a website that meets Google’s Ad Grants website policy: a domain you own, HTTPS on every page, and original content about your mission. Each ad should also lead to a page about that one program, such as “Food pantry hours” or “Volunteer on Saturdays,” rather than your homepage.

The same goes for Facebook and Instagram ads. If the page is slow, vague or hard to use on a phone, you pay for clicks that go nowhere.

Already have a grant? Our free Google Ad Grant Health Check scores your account and landing pages against Google’s rules. Our Google Ad Grants guide covers how to apply.

What makes a nonprofit website work?

People can find it, it’s quick and easy on a phone, and your team can keep it current.

Found in search. Search engine optimization (SEO) means the people who need you find you when they search. That starts with a page for each program, written in the words people search for (“free tax help in Dayton,” not “financial empowerment initiative”), plus titles, descriptions and a Google Business Profile that match.

Fast and easy to use on a phone. Speed changes behavior even in small amounts. In Google and Deloitte’s Milliseconds Make Millions study (2019 data), a site 0.1 seconds faster on mobile moved 21.6% more lead-generation visitors from the first step of a form to the submission page. Keep pages light, buttons big and forms short.

Easy for your team to update. Blog posts, events and program changes should take minutes, without calling a developer. A site that’s hard to edit goes stale, and a stale site costs you trust with donors, funders and the people you serve.

Is a custom-built site worth it?

Often, yes, and it can cost less over the years than a template site.

Fewer subscriptions. A WordPress site usually needs paid hosting from a company like Hostinger, a page builder like Elementor and a few premium plugins, and each one renews every year. A custom site is less likely to need any of them. It can run on low-cost or free hosting, so the money you’d spend on those renewals stays with you.

Faster pages and better SEO. A custom site loads only what each page needs, so it’s usually faster than a site made with a builder. Every page can be set up for search from the start, with clear headings, page titles and descriptions. Faster pages are easier to use, too, especially on a phone.

Still easy to edit. Custom code doesn’t mean your team edits code. A custom site can come with a simple dashboard where your team adds blog posts, events and program updates in a few clicks.

The trade-off is a higher cost up front. In the long run, it can still be the cheaper option, and your team gets a site built around the actions it has to bring in.

WordPress, Wix, Squarespace or custom: which builder should you choose?

Match the platform to the people who will edit it. Canva, Carrd and Squarespace are the simplest, Wix gives you more design freedom, WordPress can do almost anything but needs looking after, and a custom build is designed around the actions your site has to bring in.

What matters Canva Carrd Squarespace Wix WordPress Custom-built
Easy to edit Very easy Very easy Very easy Very easy Medium Easy, if built for your team
Design freedom Templates Templates Templates High Very high Complete
Donations Links only Links or embeds (Pro) Built-in or add-ons Built-in or add-ons Plugins Any provider
More than one language Limited Limited Limited Built-in Plugins Built-in
Upkeep Very low Very low Low Low High Low to medium
Price, billed yearly Free Free; Pro from $9 a year From $12 a month From $17 a month Free software, plus hosting from about $4 a month and a page builder like Elementor Quoted per project; low running costs
Nonprofit discount Free premium features with Canva for Nonprofits No nonprofit pricing 10% off your first payment (code NONPROFIT) 70% off 2-year Premium via TechSoup Depends on the host Depends on the builder
Best for One-page starter sites Cheap, simple one-page sites Small teams who want polish Hands-on DIY teams Bigger or complex sites Sites that must bring people in

Prices are the entry plans on each company’s pricing page, checked on November 14, 2026. They change often, so check again before you budget.

Canva has a free website builder, and eligible nonprofits get Canva’s premium features free through Canva for Nonprofits. It suits a one-page site with your hours, a short story and a link to your donation page. It isn’t built for many pages, forms or search settings, so most nonprofits outgrow it.

Carrd is one of the cheapest simple builders: a clean one-page site for a campaign, an event or a small program. The free plan covers up to 3 sites. Carrd Pro starts at $9 a year, and Pro Standard, at $19 a year, adds your own domain, forms and embeds such as a donation form. It isn’t made for many pages, so pick it when one page is enough.

Squarespace has the most polished templates of the DIY builders, and hosting, security and updates are handled for you. Plans on its pricing page start at $12 a month for Basic, which takes a 2% fee on donations; Core, at $17, has no fee. Squarespace’s nonprofit help page says to enter NONPROFIT at checkout to get 10% off your first payment.

Wix gives you drag-and-drop freedom and a large app market for donations, events and bookings. Its plans start at $17 a month. According to Wix’s help center, eligible nonprofits can get 70% off a two-year Premium plan for one site through TechSoup, plus a one-year domain voucher. After two years, it renews at the standard price.

WordPress runs a large share of the web and can do almost anything through themes and plugins. The software is free, but you need two more things. First, hosting: a company that keeps your site online, such as Hostinger, usually about $4 a month for the first term and $10 to $18 a month at renewal. Second, a page builder such as Elementor, so your team can design and edit pages without code. It also needs regular updates, backups and security care, or plugins conflict and the site slows down.

If you sell things, such as thrift store items, merch or event tickets, use a store platform. Shopify Basic costs $19 a month billed yearly. If you’re already on WordPress, WooCommerce adds a store for free, plus your hosting.

A custom-built site makes sense when a template is holding back what the site has to do: bring in donations, sign-ups or referrals, serve people in more than one language, and stay fast and accessible on older phones and screen readers. Is a custom-built site worth it? above covers the costs, and you can see how our team builds nonprofit websites.

What’s right for your nonprofit?

Start from your team and what the site has to do. Four examples:

  • A two-person food pantry that needs its hours and a donate button. Canva or Squarespace. One page, a map, opening times and a link to a donation form is enough to start.
  • A counseling nonprofit with intake forms in English and Spanish. A custom build, or WordPress with a partner who looks after it. Forms, two languages and privacy all need care that templates handle poorly.
  • A youth sports club that changes events every week. Wix or Squarespace, so a coach or volunteer can update the schedule from a phone.
  • A thrift store or merch shop. Shopify. Already on WordPress? WooCommerce.

Do you need your own domain?

Yes. Your domain is your address online, like yournonprofit.org, and Google Ad Grants requires one you own. Register both the .org and the .com of your name. Most people expect a nonprofit to be on .org, some will type .com out of habit, and owning both stops anyone else from taking the other one. Point the .com to your .org site.

We recommend buying your domains from Porkbun. It shows the renewal price upfront, not just the first year, and includes privacy for your contact details at no extra cost. Don’t buy your domain from your web host or from big registrars like GoDaddy. Many sell a cheap first year, then raise the price at every renewal, and moving your domain away later is a hassle. With your domain at a separate registrar, you can change builders or hosts and keep your address.

Turn on auto-renew so your domain never lapses.

How much does a nonprofit website cost?

A DIY site runs about $5 to $40 a month for the plan, plus a yearly fee for your domains and your team’s time to build and update it. WordPress adds upkeep: updates, backups and fixing plugins, by you or by someone you pay. A custom build costs more up front and takes less staff time after, and the price depends on the number of pages, languages, forms and donation or sign-up tools.

When you compare, count staff hours too. A $12 plan that takes a volunteer six hours a month to keep current can cost more than it looks.

What should you do next?

Answer these six questions before you pick a platform:

  1. Who will edit the site, and how often? Pick the platform that person finds easy.
  2. What must the site do? List the actions: donate, volunteer, register, ask for help.
  3. Do you need more than one language? Rule out the platforms that can’t do it well.
  4. What’s your real budget, including time? Add your staff hours to the plan price.
  5. Do you qualify for a nonprofit discount? Check our Nonprofit Tools list before you buy.
  6. Can you take your content with you? Check that you can export your pages, posts and contact data if you outgrow the platform.

Then set up the tools around the site. Our Nonprofit Tools list covers the free and discounted ones we use for websites and SEO, from hosting and security to analytics and keyword research.

Rather have a team do this for you?

Mission Circle is a nonprofit marketing team. Our Website design and development service does this work for you. A fast, accessible site that earns trust and donations.

Get my free marketing plan Free 30-min call, then a 1-hour plan session · keep the plan either way

Not sure where to focus?

In a free plan session, we’ll review your marketing and hand you a clear, prioritized plan, even if we never work together.

Your next step Get my free marketing plan Free · 30-min call, then a 1-hour plan session · no obligation Or contact us